Instagram Competitor Analysis: A Step-by-Step Method and Free Template (Works on TikTok Too)
A step-by-step Instagram competitor analysis for Reels, with a free template you can paste into Google Sheets. Find each rival's normal views, the Reels that beat it, and the formats worth making. The same method works on TikTok.
An Instagram competitor analysis for Reels comes down to four moves. Pick 5 to 10 accounts in and around your niche. Learn what a normal Reel gets on each one. Find the Reels that beat that normal by a wide margin. Then work out why they won. Every number you need is public, since the view counts sit on the thumbnails. Instagram simply won't organize them for you.
The first pass takes about an hour. After that, twenty minutes a week keeps it alive, which is roughly the length of one doomscroll you were going to have anyway. The same steps work on TikTok, with a few extra numbers covered near the end, and there's a free template below that keeps the whole analysis in one sheet.
What is an Instagram competitor analysis?
It's a short, repeatable study of the accounts your audience already watches, done to answer one question: which topics, hooks and formats are working in your niche right now?
Most competitor analysis templates ask for follower counts, posting schedules and bio wording. Those tell you very little about what to film next. The useful part is the Reels that did far better than their account usually does, because each one is a format that reached people beyond that account's own followers. That's evidence, and it's what this method is built to find.
Step 1: Pick the Instagram accounts to analyze
Most people study only their direct competitors, which is a mistake, since direct competitors are mostly guessing too. Build three layers instead:
- Direct competitors, 3 or 4 accounts. Same niche, similar audience, similar size. They show what your shared audience already responds to.
- Aspirational accounts, 2 or 3. Same niche, much bigger. Their history shows which formats scaled, and they've already made the mistakes you're about to make.
- Adjacent niches, 2 or 3. Different topic, same audience psychology. A fitness creator can lift storytelling formats from a finance creator all day and neither audience will ever notice. Doing that on purpose is the outlier transfer method.
Finding them takes minutes. Search your main keywords on both platforms, note who keeps showing up, then check who the app suggests next to them. Small accounts with big numbers deserve a slot too, and how to find small Instagram accounts getting huge views shows where to look. The list improves as you go, so don't polish it now.
Step 2: Find each competitor's normal views
Skip this step and the rest collapses, because a Reel is only impressive relative to its account's normal. 100K views is a great week for one account and a slump for another, and if you don't know which, every number you look at is noise.
Per account, you want typical views (use the median, since one viral hit distorts an average), posting frequency, and typical video length. Everything else Instagram knows about the account is private to its owner, and how to see someone else's Instagram analytics lists exactly what you can and can't see.
By hand that's a scroll-and-tally session per profile. With the free ViewRank extension, you open the profile, rank the last 100 or 200 videos, and read the stats strip: average views, median views, and on TikTok the median engagement rate plus medians for likes, comments, shares and saves. Instagram profiles also show the typical length of the account's top videos. One glance per account.
Write the medians into the template below. Next month, when a competitor's Reel crosses your feed, you'll know in a second whether it's actually working or just visible.
Step 3: Find the Reels that beat their normal
Now find every Reel at 2x its account's normal or better. These outliers are the whole point of the exercise. Each one is a topic, hook or format that provably reached an audience beyond the account's own followers.
Manually, that means holding the median in your head while comparing thumbnails. In ViewRank, set "Rank by" to Outliers and the profile re-sorts by outlier score, with green badges on everything at 2x and up, and old pinned videos excluded automatically so a two-year-old hit can't pollute the ranking. There are step-by-step walkthroughs for Instagram and TikTok if you want the detail.

Work through your whole list and star every outlier you could plausibly adapt. Skip the ones you can't. A lottery-win story going 50x teaches you nothing repeatable.
Sort any Instagram or TikTok profile in one click
The free ViewRank Chrome extension ranks any profile's videos by views, likes, comments, or outlier score, right on the page.
Add ViewRank to Chrome, it's freeStep 4: Work out why those Reels won
You should now have 20 to 40 outliers across your list. This is where the actual thinking happens, and there's no way to skim it. For each video, write down four things.
The hook, word for word. First line, first visual. Across 30 outliers, the hooks alone teach you more about your niche than any course, and you'll start seeing the same few shapes: the bold claim, the specific number, the "you're doing this wrong." If you would rather read a hook than replay it, our free Instagram reel transcript tool and TikTok transcript tool turn any public video into text you can quote.
The format, named. Talking head, voiceover over b-roll, green screen, listicle with text overlays, day-in-the-life. Naming it is what makes it rebuildable.
The topic angle, precisely. Not "productivity" but "productivity advice framed as things I'd tell my younger self." The angle is usually the transferable part, more than the topic.
Length and pacing. How long, and how often the shot changes.
Then compare them side by side. One creator with three outliers in the same format has a habit. Three creators with outliers in the same format? That's a niche-wide pattern, and patterns are as close to a guarantee as this game offers.
You can also hand the decoding to ViewRank AI. Import an outlier (there's a send button in the extension overlay) and you get the transcript, a scene-by-scene visual breakdown synced to the words, and the reasons it most likely worked. It turns an afternoon of rewatching into a few minutes of reading, though the manual version genuinely teaches you things too.
Step 5: Fill in the free competitor analysis template
Research you can't find again didn't happen. The template is one Google Sheet with two tabs, and the extension fills most of it for you.
Tab 1, Accounts. One row per competitor, filled from Steps 1 to 3.
| Column | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Account | The handle, linked to the profile |
| Group | Direct, bigger, or adjacent niche |
| Median views | From the extension's stats strip |
| Reels checked | How many you ranked, ideally 50 or more |
| Outliers | How many reached 2x their normal or more |
| Best outlier | The link and score of the top one |
| Format that repeats | The format behind most of their outliers |
Tab 2, Outliers. One row per Reel worth studying. Rank the profile, then in the extension's export menu choose Only Outliers and For Sheets, click Copy, and paste. The first eight columns arrive filled in: profile, Reel link, views, likes, comments, outlier score, and your notes and tags. Add four columns of your own to the right and fill them in as you watch, using Step 4:
| Your column | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Hook | The first line, word for word |
| Format | Talking head, voiceover over b-roll, listicle with text, and so on |
| Angle | The precise framing, not just the topic |
| Adapt? | Yes or no, with one line on how you'd do it |
To start the sheet, open a blank Google Sheet, click cell A1 on each tab, and paste the matching line below. Each heading lands in its own column.
Tab 1:
Account Group Median views Reels checked Outliers Best outlier Format that repeats
Tab 2:
Profile Reel Views Likes Comments Outlier Score Notes Tags Hook Format Angle Adapt?
A TikTok export carries more columns (shares, saves, engagement rate, date posted and caption), so give TikTok accounts their own Outliers tab and add the same four columns after the export.
If a competitor wins with carousels rather than Reels, rank their main grid by likes instead, as in how to see the most liked posts on any Instagram account, and give those posts their own tab.
Keep a swipe file alongside it, every outlier you'd adapt with its hook written out and its format named. The extension's favorites and per-video notes do this inside the overlay, and the notes and tags travel into the export.
Step 6: Turn the analysis into your content calendar
A competitor analysis doesn't produce a report. It produces your next two weeks of videos, or it produced nothing.
Take the three strongest patterns you found, meaning formats or angles with multiple outliers behind them. For each, list three topics from your own expertise that fit. Nine ideas, each with evidence behind it. Schedule them, make them, then watch which ones beat your own normal, because your outliers now feed the next cycle.

If the blank page is still the bottleneck after all that, this is the other half of what the ViewRank AI workspace does. Give it a winning reference plus your niche and audience, and it writes four ideas on the pattern that made the original work, then a complete, ready-to-record script for the one you pick. The manual version of that step is how to write a Reel script from a competitor's transcript. There's a 7-day free trial if you want to test it on a real competitor's outlier.
Want to know why those videos worked?
ViewRank AI transcribes winning videos, breaks down their visuals scene by scene, and turns the patterns into fresh ideas and scripts for your own niche. Free for 7 days. Cancel anytime.
Start your free trialHow is TikTok competitor analysis different?
Same steps, with more numbers to work with. TikTok shows shares and saves on every public video, and the ViewRank extension adds an engagement rate for each one plus the creator's median. That gives you a check Instagram can't. A TikTok outlier with engagement above the creator's median connected with the people who saw it, while one below the median was mostly pushed wide by the algorithm. Rebuild the first kind.
TikTok also has a Popular sort on creator profiles, which shows an account's biggest hits at a glance. It's a fine first look, but it doesn't compare videos with the creator's normal, so use outlier score for the analysis itself. More in how to find the most viewed videos on any TikTok account.
How often should you run a competitor analysis?
Full process, monthly. Light pass, weekly: open your list, sort each profile by Newest, and check whether anything recent is beating its normal. Fifteen minutes, and no format shift in your niche gets past you while it still matters. Recency is worth being strict about, since an outlier from last month reflects the current algorithm and mood in a way last year's simply doesn't.
The weekly pass is also the part that quietly dies first. If you would rather it ran without you, the Viral Tracker in ViewRank AI watches your chosen creators on Instagram and TikTok, re-checks them every few days, and collects any video that reaches 2x their average into one feed with its score attached. Turn on the weekly email and the week's breakouts arrive in your inbox on the day you pick. Starter covers 2 creators, Pro covers 5, which is enough for your direct competitors.

FAQ
What should you look for in an Instagram competitor analysis?
Their outlier Reels, the ones at 2x the account's normal views or better. The median tells you what's expected, and the outliers tell you what resonated. Hooks, formats and angles that repeat across several accounts' outliers are the signals worth adapting.
Is there a free Instagram competitor analysis tool?
Yes. The ViewRank Chrome extension is free and needs no account. It ranks any public Instagram or TikTok profile by views, likes, comments or outlier score, shows the account's average and median views, and exports the results for Google Sheets. For tracking that runs on its own, the Viral Tracker in ViewRank AI checks the accounts you choose every few days and can email you the week's breakouts.
Is there a free Instagram competitor analysis template?
Yes, the two-tab template in Step 5. Paste the headings into a blank Google Sheet, then paste the extension's Only Outliers export into the second tab. It works in Excel too.
How many competitor accounts should you analyze?
Five to ten. A few direct competitors, a couple of much bigger aspirational accounts, and a couple from adjacent niches that share your audience's psychology. Under five you get flukes instead of patterns. Over ten, the research stops happening.
Can you do a competitor analysis without any tools?
Yes. Views are public on Instagram Reels and on all TikTok videos, so a spreadsheet and patience cover it. Tools buy back time, turning an afternoon of tallying into a few minutes of reading, which starts to matter once you're doing this weekly.
Is it legal to analyze competitors' public social media data?
Reviewing publicly visible content and metrics is ordinary competitive research, and the platforms show those numbers to everyone. What you shouldn't do is repost or copy the actual content. Study the patterns, make your own videos.


